Preventing occupational asthma
Key points
- Reducing exposure at source is the most important action for preventing occupational asthma.
- Controls are ranked: eliminate, substitute, then engineering and organizational measures, with personal protection as the last resort.
- Respiratory protective equipment has limits and cannot be relied on to replace control at source.
- Health surveillance looks for early symptoms and sensitization, and group results show whether controls work.
Prevention starts at the source
A systematic evidence review prepared to assist the UK Health and Safety Executive concluded that the most important action to prevent occupational asthma is to reduce exposure at source. Surveillance for early identification of symptoms, including occupational rhinitis, comes next, with functional and immunological tests where appropriate.1 The same logic applies in the European framework: risks are to be tackled at the source, and measures that protect a whole group of workers come first.2
The hierarchy of controls
European worker protection law ranks measures for dangerous substances. The ranking is a legal and practical order of preference, not a menu.2
- Elimination. Change the process or product so that the substance is not used.
- Substitution. If elimination is not possible, replace the substance with a non-hazardous or less hazardous one.
- Technical and organizational measures. Control emissions at the source with a closed system or local exhaust ventilation, and reduce the number of workers exposed, the duration, and the intensity of exposure.
- Personal protective equipment. By law, this is the last resort where exposure cannot be adequately controlled by other means.2
Rules in your country may differ in detail. National legislation can add to or tighten these provisions.2
Examples from the evidence
- Latex gloves. Substituting powdered latex gloves with low-protein powder-free or latex-free gloves was linked to large reductions in latex aeroallergens, sensitization, and latex asthma among health care workers. This is the largest body of primary-prevention studies for any single asthmagen, though it is small and mostly observational.3
- Cleaning products. An expert position paper proposes substituting cleaning sprays, bleach and ammonia, minimizing the use of disinfectants, avoiding mixing products, and educating workers, with respiratory devices also on its list.4
- Enzymes in detergent manufacturing. Best-practice guidance combines engineering and hygiene programs with health surveillance, and uses group results of surveillance to prioritize improvements.5
Respiratory protection: a limited measure
Respirators are the last link in the chain, and the evidence for their efficacy in managing occupational asthma has been called lacking in evidence-based reviews.6 In a study of 20 workers with sensitizer-induced asthma from metal-working fluid aerosols, the authors report that a strictly enforced program of air-fed respirators reduced work-related falls in peak flow, but that the reduction was rarely complete, and they concluded that such equipment cannot be relied on to replace source control. It also stressed monitoring after protection is introduced.6
This is a statement about limits, not an invitation to go without protection. A worker given a respirator should use it as instructed while the employer works on higher-level controls, and should report any continuing symptoms to a doctor.
Health surveillance
Surveillance is a safety net, not a substitute for controls. Its purpose is to spot symptoms and sensitization early so that exposure can be reduced before disease becomes established.1
A best-practice protocol for workers exposed to enzymes in detergent manufacture is a useful model. It recommends surveillance every six months for the first two years and yearly afterward, combining a validated respiratory questionnaire, lung function tests, and tests for specific IgE. Because airborne measurements do not capture short peaks of exposure, the rate of new sensitization is described as the most reliable measure of the integrity of environmental control, and group results of tests help to judge whether engineering and hygiene measures work.5 The schedule is specific to that industry and agent; it is not a general standard.
When a case is identified, preventive measures for other exposed workers should be considered as well.7
Information and participation
Prevention works best when it is not left to the individual. A worker cannot substitute a product or redesign a ventilation system, so the ranking of measures places the first task on the process and the workplace, not on personal protection.2
Workers should know the hazards they face, the results of risk assessments, and the results of any exposure monitoring or health surveillance. They should know who to report problems to.2 A worker who suspects a link between symptoms and work should see a doctor and the occupational physician. Prescribed treatment should not be stopped on one's own initiative.
Related pages: exposure assessment, understanding occupational asthma, and sensitizers and irritants.
Sources
- Nicholson PJ, Cullinan P, Taylor AJ, et al. Evidence based guidelines for the prevention, identification, and management of occupational asthma. Occup Environ Med. 2005;62(5):290-9. PubMed 15837849. DOI
- EU-OSHA. Dangerous substances.
- LaMontagne AD, Radi S, Elder DS, et al. Primary prevention of latex related sensitisation and occupational asthma: a systematic review. Occup Environ Med. 2006;63(5):359-64. PubMed 16469822. DOI
- Siracusa A, De Blay F, Folletti I, et al. Asthma and exposure to cleaning products - a European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology task force consensus statement. Allergy. 2013;68(12):1532-45. PubMed 24131133. DOI
- Nicholson PJ, Newman Taylor AJ, Oliver P, et al. Current best practice for the health surveillance of enzyme workers in the soap and detergent industry. Occup Med (Lond). 2001;51(2):81-92. PubMed 11307694. DOI
- Ilgaz A, Moore VC, Robertson AS, et al. Occupational asthma; the limited role of air-fed respiratory protective equipment. Occup Med (Lond). 2019;69(5):329-335. PubMed 31269209. DOI
- Tarlo SM, Balmes J, Balkissoon R, et al. Diagnosis and management of work-related asthma: American College Of Chest Physicians Consensus Statement. Chest. 2008;134(3 Suppl):1S-41S. PubMed 18779187. DOI
- Vandenplas O, Godet J, Hurdubaea L, et al. Severe Occupational Asthma: Insights From a Multicenter European Cohort. J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract. 2019;7(7):2309-2318.e4. PubMed 30914232. DOI
AsmaNet publishes educational information that does not replace advice from a doctor or occupational health professional. If someone is struggling to breathe, call your local emergency number. This content has not been reviewed by a clinician.