Asthma education programs and the evidence
Key points
- Asthma education programs, called asthma schools in France, help patients understand and manage their condition.
- In adults and children, systematic reviews link them with fewer hospital admissions and emergency visits.
- Effects on measured lung function are inconsistent, and it is unclear which format works best.
- Programs do not replace medical follow-up. They add to it.
This page presents the idea of patient education and the data that assess it. It deliberately lists no programs and no addresses: offers change, and your doctor or health service is the right person to point you to what exists near you.
The idea
In France, "écoles de l'asthme" (asthma schools) are structures that offer therapeutic education: sessions, individual or in groups, teaching people with asthma and those around them to understand the disease, recognize signs of worsening, use their treatment and apply a written action plan. A patient association states that it created asthma schools in France.1 This sits within a wider movement: WHO notes that people with asthma and their families need education about treatment options, triggers to avoid and managing symptoms at home.2
Content varies from one program to another. It usually covers understanding the disease, triggers, inhalers, monitoring of symptoms or peak flow, and what to do when asthma worsens.
Evidence in adults
A Cochrane review (2003) pooled 36 randomized trials comparing self-management education with usual care in adults with asthma. Education reduced hospital admissions (relative risk 0.64), emergency visits (0.82), unscheduled doctor visits (0.68), days off work or school (0.79) and nocturnal asthma (0.67), and quality of life improved, while measures of lung function changed little.3 The authors conclude that education combined with monitoring, regular medical review and a written action plan improves health outcomes. Programs that taught people to adjust treatment using a written plan appeared more effective than others.3 That last point does not mean adjusting treatment on your own: such plans are drawn up and agreed with the clinician.
Evidence in children
- In children who had already attended an emergency department for asthma, a review (38 studies, 7,843 children) found that education, directed to the child, parents or both, reduced the risk of a further emergency visit (RR 0.73) and of hospital admission (RR 0.79). Effects on quality of life, symptoms and lung function were not significant, and data were scarce.4
- Another review (32 studies, 3,706 patients aged 2 to 18) reported a moderate improvement in airflow measures and in self-efficacy, and modest reductions in school absence, restricted-activity days and emergency visits. Effects were larger in moderate to severe asthma.5
- School-based interventions probably reduce hospital admissions and slightly improve children's quality of life, but their effect on school absence is uncertain, and most studies were done in North America among socially disadvantaged populations.6 Interventions that involved parents and had a theoretical framework were more often implemented successfully.6
What these studies do not say
These reviews have limits. The authors stress that it is unclear which type, duration or intensity of program is most effective,4 and that components have rarely been compared directly.5 One review also reports uncertainty about long-term effects on quality of life, symptoms and lung function.4 Most of these reviews are older (2003 to 2009): more recent reviews may exist, and local practice may not match what the trials tested. Finally, education alone is not enough: treatment, follow-up and trigger reduction remain necessary.
Making use of it
- Ask your family doctor, lung specialist or pharmacist, who know what is offered in your area.
- Bring your inhaler and action plan to work on during sessions.
- For a child, involve the parents: their involvement helps programs succeed.6
- Think about the written action plan and the management principles.
Written action plans as part of education
Written action plans are a core element of most programs. In children, a 2006 Cochrane review of four trials involving 355 children found a lower risk of exacerbations needing acute care with symptom-based plans than with peak flow-based plans (relative risk 0.73), and noted that trials in which the only difference was the written plan itself were scarce.7 See management principles.
Who may benefit most
In the 2003 review of education programs for children, effects were greater for most outcomes in moderate to severe asthma than in mild to moderate asthma, were already visible within six months, and were clearer for illness measures and health service use by twelve months.5
Sources
- Association Asthme & Allergies. Asthme & Allergies.
- World Health Organization. Asthma: fact sheet.
- Gibson PG, Powell H, Coughlan J, et al. Self-management education and regular practitioner review for adults with asthma. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2003(1):CD001117. PubMed 12535399. DOI
- Boyd M, Lasserson TJ, McKean MC, et al. Interventions for educating children who are at risk of asthma-related emergency department attendance. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;2009(2):CD001290. PubMed 19370563. DOI
- Wolf FM, Guevara JP, Grum CM, et al. Educational interventions for asthma in children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2003;2002(1):CD000326. PubMed 12535395. DOI
- Harris K, Kneale D, Lasserson TJ, et al. School-based self-management interventions for asthma in children and adolescents: a mixed methods systematic review. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2019;1(1):CD011651. PubMed 30687940. DOI
- Bhogal S, Zemek R, Ducharme FM. Written action plans for asthma in children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006(3):CD005306. PubMed 16856090. DOI
AsmaNet publishes educational information that does not replace advice from a doctor or occupational health professional. If someone is struggling to breathe, call your local emergency number. This content has not been reviewed by a clinician.