Pets, animal dander and asthma: choices without false promises
Key points
- Animal fur and feathers are listed among triggers that can worsen asthma in some people, not in everyone.
- Evidence on removing a pet from the home is limited, and a large review found no clear benefit from single allergen-reduction measures.
- Do not rely on a pet being sold as hypoallergenic. No study cited here supports such a promise.
- Work with laboratory animals is a documented occupational risk for sensitization and asthma.
Animals as an asthma trigger
The World Health Organization lists animal fur and feathers among the triggers that can bring on or worsen asthma symptoms, together with dust, smoke, fumes, and pollen.1 As with every trigger, the effect varies. Some people with asthma notice no obvious change around animals, and others notice clear reactions. A clinician who knows the person's history is the right guide to whether animals matter in a particular case. For a wider look at how triggers are identified, see the page on asthma triggers.
Two situations deserve different handling. One is a person already living with a pet, where the question is whether to keep it. The other is a family choosing whether to bring an animal home. Evidence is thin in both cases, and the honest answer in this section is often "ask a clinician who can look at the whole picture".
What trials of pet removal found
A systematic review prepared to inform US asthma guidelines examined eight allergen reduction interventions, one of them pet removal. Across the 59 randomized and 8 nonrandomized trials it reviewed, the evidence for most interventions and outcomes was inconclusive or showed no effect. Single interventions were generally not associated with improvement, and none improved validated asthma control scores or lung function.2 Its published summary gives no separate result for pet removal, so it shows neither that removing a pet works nor that it fails.
The same review found more encouraging results for multicomponent programs, with fewer exacerbations in studies that included HEPA vacuums or pest control.2 A large 2004 trial in US inner-city children, using an individualized home program tailored to each child's sensitizations, reported fewer days with symptoms in the intervention group than in the comparison group.3 Neither source can tell you whether a pet should leave a particular home.
"Hypoallergenic" pets and other promises
Marketing sometimes presents certain breeds or animals as safe for people with allergies. This page rests on no study showing that any breed or species is free of risk for people with asthma, and it advises against making such a claim the basis of a decision. If a pet is being considered for a household where someone has asthma or allergy, a conversation with a clinician before the decision is more reliable than a label.
It is also worth saying what avoidance cannot do. Moving a pet out of the home, or never acquiring one, is not a replacement for prescribed treatment, and you should not lower or stop medicines because an animal has gone. Medicine changes are a matter for your clinician.
Animals at work
For some people the main animal exposure is occupational. In a prospective cohort of 417 apprentices in animal-health technology, 28 met the study's definition of probable occupational asthma, an incidence of 2.7 per 100 person-years. Skin reactivity to pets at the start, and airway responsiveness, were associated with a higher risk.4 That study is older (2001) and it concerned a specific training population, so it should not be generalized to every pet owner. It adds to the evidence that work with animals can carry a risk of occupational asthma. See the section on sensitizers and irritants at work for how workplace asthma is assessed.
Questions worth asking your clinician
- Is there evidence that animals trigger my (or my child's) symptoms, or is this a guess?
- Is my asthma well controlled right now, and does that change the discussion?
- If we consider a pet, what would a sensible plan look like, and what would tell us it is not working?
- Does my work involve animal exposure, and should I mention it?
Related pages
See dust mites and asthma for another indoor allergen with similar evidence limits, indoor air, and triggers at home and school.
Sources
- World Health Organization. Asthma: fact sheet.
- Leas BF, D’Anci KE, Apter AJ, et al. Effectiveness of indoor allergen reduction in asthma management: A systematic review. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2018;141(5):1854-1869. PubMed 29452202. DOI
- Morgan WJ, Crain EF, Gruchalla RS, et al. Results of a home-based environmental intervention among urban children with asthma. N Engl J Med. 2004;351(11):1068-80. PubMed 15356304. DOI
- Gautrin D, Infante-Rivard C, Ghezzo H, et al. Incidence and host determinants of probable occupational asthma in apprentices exposed to laboratory animals. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2001;163(4):899-904. PubMed 11282763. DOI
AsmaNet publishes educational information that does not replace advice from a doctor or occupational health professional. If someone is struggling to breathe, call your local emergency number. This content has not been reviewed by a clinician.